EyeBuyDirect vs Warby Parker (2026): Price, Progressives, Returns and Try-On
EyeBuyDirect and Warby Parker compared on starting prices, progressive lenses, shipping, returns, insurance and try-on – and which one fits your budget and prescription.
Disclosure: We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. It never affects our ratings. How we make money.
On this page
Short answer: EyeBuyDirect costs far less – frames from $6 and progressives from $49 on eligible frames – if you’re comfortable buying entirely online. Warby Parker costs more (from $95 with lenses, progressives from $325) but gives you stores where you can try frames, get an eye exam and be fitted in person.
Facts below come from each retailer’s own website (EyeBuyDirect checked October 22, Warby Parker October 20, 2026). This comparison is based on published information, not a hands-on test.
Side-by-side
| EyeBuyDirect | Warby Parker | |
|---|---|---|
| Glasses from | $6 (frame tiers $19 / $39 / $69 / $70+) | $95 including prescription lenses |
| Progressives | Lenses from $49 on eligible frames; package from $99 | From $325 (Signature), $395 (Precision), frames included |
| US shipping | $5.95 (USPS, 7–14 business days); free over $119 | Free |
| Returns | 30 days: full refund or one-time replacement | Free 30-day returns |
| Defect coverage | 365-day guarantee: one replacement pair | – |
| Vision insurance | Accepted | Vision benefits accepted |
| Try-on | Virtual try-on | Virtual try-on in its app; physical stores |
| Eye exams | No | In its stores |
Swipe to see the full table →
”–” = not stated on the retailer’s site.
Price: what a pair actually costs
Single vision: Warby Parker’s $95 includes basic prescription lenses and free shipping, so $95 is close to your total. At EyeBuyDirect, a $19-tier frame plus $5.95 shipping is $24.95 before lens upgrades – see the worked examples in is EyeBuyDirect legit?.
Progressives: the gap is widest here. EyeBuyDirect’s progressive package with 1.6 lenses and coatings is listed at $99 (plus $5.95 shipping under $119), compared with Warby Parker’s $325 starting price. See best places to buy progressive glasses online.
Returns and fit
Both stores give you 30 days. Warby Parker returns are free; EyeBuyDirect gives a full refund or a one-time replacement of equal or lesser value. If you need more time to decide, GlassesUSA offers 60 days.
Fit is where Warby Parker earns its price: you can try frames, have your pupillary distance measured and get adjustments in a store. Online, you’ll rely on your current frame size and an accurate PD – see our frame size guide and how to measure your PD.
Which should you choose?
Pick EyeBuyDirect if:
- Price matters most, or you need progressives on a budget.
- You know your frame size and have your PD.
- You want several pairs (free shipping over $119).
Pick Warby Parker if:
- You want to try frames on and be fitted in person.
- You want an eye exam and glasses in one place.
- You prefer a single all-in price with free shipping and returns.
EyeBuyDirect
Best valueBest for: Budget shoppers and progressive wearers buying online
- Frames from $6
- Progressives from $49 on eligible frames
- 365-day defect guarantee
- $5.95 shipping under $119
- No stores or in-person fittings
More options: Warby Parker review · Zenni vs Warby Parker · Warby Parker alternatives · best places to buy glasses online.
Shop EyeBuyDirectKey takeaways
- EyeBuyDirect starts at $6 for frames; Warby Parker starts at $95 including prescription lenses.
- For progressives, EyeBuyDirect lists lenses from $49 on eligible frames (packages from $99); Warby Parker starts at $325 (Signature) or $395 (Precision) including frames.
- Both give 30 days to return; Warby Parker ships free, while EyeBuyDirect charges $5.95 unless you spend $119.
- Warby Parker has physical stores with eye exams and fittings; its free Home Try-On program has ended in favor of in-app virtual try-on.
- Choose EyeBuyDirect to spend less, especially on progressives; choose Warby Parker if you want to try frames in person or get fitted in a store.
Frequently asked questions
Is EyeBuyDirect cheaper than Warby Parker?
Usually, yes. EyeBuyDirect frames start at $6 (with tiers at $19, $39 and $69) before lens upgrades, while Warby Parker starts at $95 including basic prescription lenses. The gap is largest for progressives: from $49 on eligible EyeBuyDirect frames versus $325 at Warby Parker.
Which has the better return policy?
They are similar on time: both allow 30 days. Warby Parker returns are free; EyeBuyDirect offers a full refund or a one-time replacement within 30 days of receipt.
Does Warby Parker still do free Home Try-On?
No. Warby Parker's free Home Try-On program has ended; it now points shoppers to virtual try-on in its app and to its stores.
Can I use vision insurance at both?
Yes. Both EyeBuyDirect and Warby Parker say they accept vision insurance; check your plan's in-network or out-of-network rules first.